Page 1 of 1
If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 12:36 am
by Globetrotter
Just for fun, with my own rankings based mainly on quality wins and losses
- 1 LSU 10 0
2 Oke St 10 0
3 Alabama 8 1
4 Arkansas 9 1
5 Oke 8 1
6 Clemson 9 1
7 Oregon 9 1
8 Stanford 9 1
9 Va Tech 9 1
10 Houston 10 0
11 Nebraska 8 2
12 Michigan St 8 2
13 Boise St 8 1
14 S Miss 9 1
15 Kansas St 8 2
16 Ga 8 2
17 Wisconsin 8 2
18 TCU 8 2
19 Penn St 8 2
20 USC 8 2
21 SC 8 2
22 Arkansas St 8 2
23 Michigan 8 2
24 Cincinnati 7 2
Matchups
- 1 SEC LSU 16 WAC Nevada
8 at large Stanford 9 at large Va Tech
4 at large Arkansas 13 Big East Cincinnati
5 at large Oke 12 MWest TCU
3 at large Alabama 14 Sun Belt Arkansas St
6 ACC Clemson 11 Big Ten Mich St
2 Big 12 Oke St 15 MAC N Illinois
7 Pac 12 Oregon 10 Con USA Houston
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 1:02 am
by Globetrotter
Just looking at some scenarios that should be pretty interesting. Things I had not thought about before with conference championships.
The Clemson v Va Tech Conference champ should be pretty sweet
Con USA championship between Houston and Southern Miss should be good
The Big Ten Championship should be a snoozer.
The Pac 12 might just see Oregon v Someone awful from the south like UCLA. That team might not even have a winning record. Really bad first championship game. I bet they wish USC could play.
I did not realize all three of the top SEC teams LSU, Arkansas and Alabama were in the West. Will be interesting to see what happens if Arkansas beats LSU and all are 11-1 with only losses to eachother. Then what if whomever wins that tie breaker loses in the championship game to Ga or SC?
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sun Dec 04, 2011 1:03 am
by Globetrotter
If there were playoffs final edition
Round 1
16 La Tech @ 1LSU
9 Clemson @ 8 Kansas St*
13 West Va @ 4 Stanford*
12 S Miss @ 5 Arkansas*
14 Arkansas St @ 3 Oke State
11 TCU @ 6 Wisconsin
10 Va Tech* @ 7 Oregon
15 N Illinois @ 2 Alabama*
*At large teams
This is based off my ratings. I will add some others based on other rankings...sagarin, colley ap. Rules are the same though, all 11 conference champs make it and seeding is based off overall ranking.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sun Dec 04, 2011 8:57 am
by footballguy51
How did you pick the at large spots?
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sun Dec 04, 2011 10:23 am
by Globetrotter
footballguy51 wrote:How did you pick the at large spots?
I did my own rankings based off quality wins and losses only.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2011 10:38 am
by kdog27
The BCS bowl matchups this year are crap.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2011 12:33 pm
by Globetrotter
Michigan has just one win against a ranked team. How they jump Kansas St is beyond me.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2011 12:47 pm
by kdog27
Globetrotter wrote:Michigan has just one win against a ranked team. How they jump Kansas St is beyond me.
VT got blownout by Clemson twice and didn't beat anybody. I know it all about money and fanbases but KSU and Boise deserved those spots way more.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2011 12:57 pm
by footballguy51
kdog27 wrote:Globetrotter wrote:Michigan has just one win against a ranked team. How they jump Kansas St is beyond me.
VT got blownout by Clemson twice and didn't beat anybody. I know it all about money and fanbases but KSU and Boise deserved those spots way more.
I completely agree. Boise and KSU earned those spots. Between that, and having an all-SEC national championship game, perhaps there will be enough irritated people to call for a playoff system rather than this joke we have going on.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sat Dec 10, 2011 8:02 pm
by NWLB
Why is NIU in the tourney?
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sat Dec 10, 2011 8:42 pm
by footballguy51
NWLB wrote:Why is NIU in the tourney?
Conference champion.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sat Dec 10, 2011 9:01 pm
by NWLB
Oh. So they are a first round bye for the Okies.
Re: If there were playoffs
Posted: Sun Dec 11, 2011 6:08 am
by footballguy51
I thought they were listed as a first round by for the Crimson Tide. Not unlike the NCAA Basketball Tourney, were the conference champion earns a seed 12-16, and the 7 at-large bids from the ACC get seeded 2-7.