TG1996 wrote:. And, with an offense that couldn't move the ball down hill with a running start in their first year (except for a win against the Steelers. HA!

), they take Courtney Brown. Now alot of that, admittedly, is hind sight since they had a crappy defense, too, but after watching Shaun Alexander go nuts in the Orange Bowl that year, he was just SCREAMING to be taken in that draft.
Courtney was absolutely the right pick there, IMO. If I would've drafted, I would've taken Brown without a doubt. There was no way in hell that they would've taken Shaun Alexander.
Going into that draft the Browns had a pathetic offense and the worst DL in football. I, like many other fans, was begging for a DL upgrade in the draft. As the draft rolled around there was a top tier of prospects...the truly great ones that you supposedly cannot miss on

. That list was Peter Warrick, Chris Samuels, Lavar Arrington, and Courtney Brown. All had been as dominant as could be in college. Warrick dropped to the bottom of the list with poor pre-draft workouts, but Courtney and Lavar wowed the scouts with their workouts and were the surefire #1 & #2. Courtney turned in a 4.48 40 yard dash at something like 280 pounds which was just sick. Combine the physical freak of nature with his total dominance at PSU (something like 17 or 18 sacks his senior year), and his continued health he was a GREAT pick at #1...apparently.
Shaun Alexander, conversely, was considered at least one or two tiers below these players. I think he ended up going around 16 or 17 overall? You simply cannot take a player projected at that area with the #1 overall pick. Shaun was good in college, and I was higher on him than most. I would've taken him with a top 10, personally, but I wouldn't have taken him #1 overall. If I had that #1 pick I woulda flipped a coin and taken Brown or Arrington. I thought both were cannot miss top notch prospects.
Looking back, sure its easy to say that Alexander, and probably countless other later picks, would've been better than Courtney Brown. At the time had the Browns drafted Alexander #1 overall the braintrust would've been run out of town (which they eventually were anyway).
The NFL draft is a tough thing to predict. Good players turn lousy, and vice versa. You have to rely on your scouting and a lot of luck. In the Browns first 2 seasons they pissed away all the extra draft picks they received and drafted some of the worst players you can imagine. Courtney Brown is one pick that I will not fault them. There is simply no way to predict how many injuries a player will sustain in his career. He goes down as a big bust, no doubt about it, but its tough to blame the FO for drafting a guy thought to be a surefire, can't miss guy who just ended up being super injury prone.