Steve Raichlen discusses water smokers
http://barbecuebible.com/2014/09/09/gui ... r-smokers/" target="_blank
I have some small quibbles with a couple of points, but who am I to argue with Steve Raichlen.
Weber Smoky Mountain
-
Lord_Byron
- Minister of Silly Walks

- Posts: 2158
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 11:04 am
- Location: Rochester NY
Re: Weber Smoky Mountain
BG '79
Twitter: @Vapid_Inanities
Twitter: @Vapid_Inanities
-
hammb
- The Stabber of Cherries

- Posts: 14321
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 12:21 pm
- Location: Bowling Green
Re: Weber Smoky Mountain
Good stuff Byron.
My main quibble is with the contention that putting beer or other liquid in the pan will in any way alter flavor of the final product. I think we all know that when you boil a flavored liquid the water boils off and the flavor elements are concentrated. That's exactly what happens when you waste money putting beer, pop, or anything else in the water pan. You end up with meat that tastes the same, and a really concentrated (likely quite STICKY) mess of liquid in your water pan...
Personally I don't put water in the pan at all for most cooks. I use it as a safety net if temps start to get too high, I'll add some cool water to knock it down a bit.
My main quibble is with the contention that putting beer or other liquid in the pan will in any way alter flavor of the final product. I think we all know that when you boil a flavored liquid the water boils off and the flavor elements are concentrated. That's exactly what happens when you waste money putting beer, pop, or anything else in the water pan. You end up with meat that tastes the same, and a really concentrated (likely quite STICKY) mess of liquid in your water pan...
Personally I don't put water in the pan at all for most cooks. I use it as a safety net if temps start to get too high, I'll add some cool water to knock it down a bit.
-
Pete Segaard
- Peregrine

- Posts: 905
- Joined: Wed May 11, 2005 2:50 pm
- Location: The banks of the mighty Portage River
Re: Weber Smoky Mountain
My first brisket on the Weber Smoky Mountain.


Started the brisket at 6:00 pm with a salt and pepper rub, used hickory chunks with lump charcoal, and pulled the brisket off at 4:00 am when the smoker would only get to 200 degrees. Finished it off in the oven till it hit 195 degrees internal.
I started with two seven pound Texas Flat briskets and ended up with just under 6 pounds trimmed.
I added an extra chunk of hickory at midnight, probably should not have done that. There is just a little bit of bitterness that I think is too much smoke.
So far though this morning I have gotten five likes.


Started the brisket at 6:00 pm with a salt and pepper rub, used hickory chunks with lump charcoal, and pulled the brisket off at 4:00 am when the smoker would only get to 200 degrees. Finished it off in the oven till it hit 195 degrees internal.
I started with two seven pound Texas Flat briskets and ended up with just under 6 pounds trimmed.
I added an extra chunk of hickory at midnight, probably should not have done that. There is just a little bit of bitterness that I think is too much smoke.
So far though this morning I have gotten five likes.
Team Falcon Around
The Falcon formerly known as oaklane2
The Falcon formerly known as oaklane2