Just to change a discussion around here for once, do you really think Urban is the best coach in history. I think there was a time you could interchange him and Saban at 1 and 2 of current coaches. The past 5+ years about shuts the door for me. Saban has sustained his success for 10 straight years now. What is it 6 chips to 3? Meanwhile Urban leaves clouds everywhere he leaves. Now, Saban is older but I dont see a drop off for at least a few more seasons. Urban is way too flaky to ever catch him IMO.hammb wrote:An Urban Meyer level coach could take an average FCS school and win 6 games with our typical MAC schedule, IMO. We went from Gary Blackney to one of the best coaches in college football (history?). That will ALWAYS result in an instant turnaround.Beaker wrote:Reading that reminded me of how at the time I was thinking this Harris kid is a good athlete but he can't hit the side of a barn passing. I remember saying how we needed to find someone who could throw the ball and stick Harris at running back. Eh.....Schadenfreude wrote:Here's a look back.Falconfreak90 wrote:Like Gary Blackney in 2000. He knew for the good of the program, he had to step aside.MarkL wrote:Any chance in the world Jinks will resign to avoid the professional embarrassment of being fired?
http://www.toledoblade.com/Opinion/2000 ... n-end.html" target="_blank
I could be wrong, but I think Blackney might have been in the last year of his contract anyway. So I don't think he gave away any money by announcing his forthcoming resignation (and I wouldn't expect any head coach to do that, anyway).
Even so, it was a nice way for Blackney to exit. It resolved debate among fans about what would happen next, and Paul Krebs had plenty of time to find the right person.
That article takes me back to a time when people following the program thought it couldn't get any lower. It was amazing how the turnaround was just over the horizon and we didn't know it. Maybe our turn around might be closer than we think. It's all about finding the right leadership.
If we do decide to move on from coach Jinks this year (god I hope so), I don't expect to find the next Urban. I'd be content finding the next Clawson, and knowing it will take a few years to see those results.
It should be fairly obvious right away though that things are on the right track. It was with Clawson, and obviously was with Meyer.
Miami
Re: Miami
Re: Miami
Perhaps Moose has looked at Greg Fundraiser's plan for the hockey team (let it get bad, then worse, then threaten to cut, huge donations, rebuild), and decided to try it with football.jpfalcon09 wrote:I wouldn't be surprised if Jinks is given one more year only because of the financials. In that case, you're looking at entering Kent/Miami territory of being irrelevant for an extended period of time. You already have awful student turnout at home games and without the promotions they ran for Maryland and EKU, you're looking at a dwindling alumni and townspeople base willing to spend their time and money on a program sinking in quicksand. It's already difficult enough to survive as a mid-major at the FBS level but leaving Jinks here another season just pushes that timeline back another year of trying to repair an immense amount of damage done.
Obviously I'm joking, but it was a hell of a fundraising move. And has returned a storied program to relevancy again.
Phi or Die
Re: Miami
No, I do not think Urban is the best coach in history. And I agree saban is the better coach for this era. I specifically said "one of the best" in college football, which he is clearly in the top 5 of coaches over the past 20 years. And he's probably got an argument to be I'm the upper echelon of the all time discussion.kdog27 wrote: Just to change a discussion around here for once, do you really think Urban is the best coach in history. I think there was a time you could interchange him and Saban at 1 and 2 of current coaches. The past 5+ years about shuts the door for me. Saban has sustained his success for 10 straight years now. What is it 6 chips to 3? Meanwhile Urban leaves clouds everywhere he leaves. Now, Saban is older but I dont see a drop off for at least a few more seasons. Urban is way too flaky to ever catch him IMO.
I'm not a fan of how he's acted of late. Nor am I a fan of how out of hand he let his program get at UF. Still, few coaches are better at winning. Saban has changed the narrative a bit by being at bama so long, but it's not as though either has/had a great reputation for loyalty. And both have shown the ability to be great at many stops/levels. It's impressive.
I don't fully believe either of them have done it without bending the rules of college football behind the scenes, but that's where we're at with the sport right now.
- Flipper
- The Global Village Idiot

- Posts: 18315
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 1:01 am
- Location: Ida Twp, MI
Re: Miami
Meyer has done one thing that no one else has done and it makes him a serious contender to be the GOAT. He's won in three distinct geographic regions. And by won I mean National Titles or at least a top five finish. He went 22-2 at Utah and finished 4th in his second yer, won it all at Florida and Ohio State. That's out west, deep south and midwest. Who else can say that?
It's not the fall that hurts...it's when you hit the ground.
Re: Miami
That is a good point Flipper. He's been a great coach with national level success at 3 regions, and obviously was incredibly successful at BG as well. Saban is, IMO, the best coach in college football over the past decade, but he was only mildly successful at MSU; he needed to go to the SEC (for whatever reason) to achieve national level success.Flipper wrote:Meyer has done one thing that no one else has done and it makes him a serious contender to be the GOAT. He's won in three distinct geographic regions. And by won I mean National Titles or at least a top five finish. He went 22-2 at Utah and finished 4th in his second yer, won it all at Florida and Ohio State. That's out west, deep south and midwest. Who else can say that?
- Schadenfreude
- Professional tractor puller

- Posts: 6983
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 7:39 am
- Location: Colorado
Re: Miami
I'm more impressed with coaches that take their programs to the next level. Joe Paterno made some serious off-the-field mistakes, but he took a program that wasn't much more than MAC caliber and led the into the Big Ten. By that standard, the best argument for Meyer is what he did at Utah. Had he stuck around, maybe he could have accomplished even more there.
Re: Miami
I have a guess whyhammb wrote: he (Saban) needed to go to the SEC (for whatever reason) to achieve national level success.
MarkL has spoken.
You may all now return to your daily lives.
You may all now return to your daily lives.
- Class of 61
- Peregrine

- Posts: 4565
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 10:51 am
- Location: Seven Hills, Ohio 44131
Re: Miami
Quite an article. Only in the SEC? Seems like OSU gets a LOT of southern kids.
Education our Challenge, Excellence our goal. (look it up)
Re: Miami
Miami played Western tight in a high scoring game. But Western held Miami to 55 rushing yards after nearly hitting 300 on us. Wow.
MarkL has spoken.
You may all now return to your daily lives.
You may all now return to your daily lives.

